Suggestion: PMU Forum Overhaul

I hope you guys at PMU like suggestions, I’ve got some! But I think perhaps this is the suggestion I should start with because this ol’ forum could benefit from an update and it lays the foundation for future improvements. What I’m trying (and probably failing) to target is ease of use and good communication.

What would change: The entire PMU forum would be scrutinized. Move a few things here and there, post a few necessary topics, build a few categories and forums, and shake your heads disapprovingly at the god-awful results while shaking your fists and shouting “Why, that PoochieHead has bamboozled us yet again!”
Haha, I’m kidding…! I hope.

For example,

[ul]Create a new forum category titled “The Archives.” A locked forum (no new posts) titled “Archived” would be made there, and forum parts that are no longer necessary or relevant would be moved there to die peacefully.

[li]The PMU 7 forum? Archived.[/li]

[li]A new forum category titled “PMU Development” to be added, located under the Pokémon Mystery Universe category and above General. The Suggestions and Contributions, Support, Map Editor, and Skins forums would then find a new home here.[/li]

[li]A new subforum would be added to Suggestions, titled “Acknowledged.” Suggestions that have been acknowledged by the staff would be moved there in a timely fashion if they are to be accepted. Currently, you don’t necessarily know if your suggestion is going to be implemented and the Acknowledged subforum would be a great way to communicate just that![/li]

[li]A sticky is to be posted in Suggestions with some kind of simple guideline template and a reminder for people to search in Acknowledged before posting. Ideally you could simply merge it with shocky’s compendium and put the original list under a spoiler tag. Something like (still with the links of course):[/li]
A compilation of suggestions that have been made so we don’t need to make repeat threads:

Maps/Dungeons

A Lais Cave Type Dungeon

Anther New Dungeon

Mar Island and Trick Cave

The Ultimate Dungeon

Deep Waters

Game

InGame tutorial

Bank Stockpiling

PvP

No More PvP

Moves

Eruption & Hyper Beam

Hyper Beam

Forums

~ Forum Avatar Off-Site File-Size Change Suggestion ~

A Signature Limit

Map Editor

External Map Editor

May Need A Smaller Map Editor

Items

Defrost items

Equip Upgrading

Events

Events

Event Suggestions

Royal

Other

Rankings

Random Idea

Suggestions from an intelligent player.

Motd

LOTS of Red8787/ZurX"s sugestions

[li]Bugs subforum to be removed from Support and given its own forum. This change might need extra justification, so consider this: I think Bugs is the most important subforum on the entire domain, and having it under Support might result in people posting their errors in Support instead of Bugs (and it already has). [/li]

[li]A sticky to be added in Bugs with an error reporting template. I’m surprised you guys didn’t have one already! Also the last properly filed (i.e. posted in the Bugs subforum) error report was in April. April! I experienced a bug on my first darn day, but I didn’t have a forum account at the time with which to report it. I hope the community can improve in this regard, after all, PMU could use all the help it can get![/ul][/li]
Why would it change: These are some varied change suggestions for the PMU forum and at first glance it might just seem like a laundry list or a plain update. What binds all of these suggestions together, however, is their goal. I believe these changes, no matter how small they might seem individually, will add up to a forum that’s even more organized, clear, and easy to use than it already is!

When would it change: I think a realistic time frame to achieve this might range from as soon as a couple of days to as late as a week, depending on how busy or burdened the forum staff is at the moment.

Have any questions? Ask them! Criticism? Point it out! My ideas are nothin’ special, 5/10 mediocre at best, so I welcome all discussion and dissection as long as we stay constructive and try to move forward.
Thanks for taking the time to read it!

P.S. a font face code would be awesome!

owo Wow. Okay. First of all, kudos to you for putting in tons of effort to organize, highlight, and explain your ideas. Greatest suggestion thread I’ve seen in a while. Also nice avatar. I love Persona 4!

As for the content of the actual suggestion itself, I agree with pretty much everything you’ve pointed out. The archives sound like a great idea, especially since people like reviving threads. Not to mention and update on acknowledged solutions / suggestions sounds like a fantastic idea to reduce redo suggestions and to help others look for the information they need to write something up. Even a temporary update to these lists would be great. Those threads haven’t been touched in ages!

The Forums have long been a place for meaningful discussions and constructive debates. It’s time they got a little love in return. :’)

[sprays soda-spittle everywhere]

You mean… it’s not the worst suggestion ever? O-oh… well, okay! Thanks! If you (or anyone for that matter) have anything to add, let me know and I might edit it in.

Actually, this idea is “Very” good. I had a similar thing in mind a few months back that kept dropping off my radar (although I was also thinking about a graphical overhaul as well, since the forum is pretty bland, and has been nearly the same thing visually for the past 5 years, save for very minor changes).

We’ll try working on some kind of forum overhaul in the future. Thank you for the very well worded and structured suggestion. Feel free to suggest other ideas~