Heart Scale

Suggestions and Contributions
1

I know it is an old topic and all, but still… Heart Scale’s current state is horrible. It rarely spawns in walls, is being hidden and it gives a random egg move when there are around 10 egg moves on most evolutionary families. It would be really frustrating to find and use 10 or more of them and get lame moves or moves that you don’t need. So, wouldn’t it better to have them hidden on the floor or letting us choose the move we want, much like at Electivire’s? Even though I do realize egg moves aren’t supposed to be easy to get but their current aviability it’s really hard to get a move you want. I’m sure a Pichu wouldn’t be very happy getting Wish (bitter irony) since it has 15 egg moves. I’m also sure many people would agree with me. I hope the staff team will get my point.

2

I agree. Heart scale should be at LEAST Hidden on the ground like Big Mushrooms. I have used 47 Heart scales, and still haven’t gotten my desired move. That’s kinda based on luck and the fact it’s rare to find and walls only, the random move chance makes it a Double Negative.

3

I agree with art . The only way i can find an HS is by Bringing 4 pickup pokemon and run tough Winden Pass…which is really time consuming considering pick up has 10% chance of working and theres about 10 items the pokemon will pick up [mostly fail 1poke].I would like to be able to select the move you want…though it would be 2 easy. Puting them on the floor makes pokemon be able to pick up the item and us having a chance of fainting the pokemon and making it drop it. I really wish staff look at this because alot of us PMU Players want an egg move to use in training / arena.Also Heart Scales are only for Moves , Why is an item that is made for learning moves so rare?? Items that should be that rare should be really good Tms , Hold items , and other items that arent ment for moves that noobs can get in eggs from Easter.

4

yes i would have to agree with this because i tried to teach my typhlosion fury swipes once i got;

-foresight
-double kick
-extrasensory
-covet
-thrash
-howl
-nature power
-quick attack
-double-edge
-flare blitz (sucks)
-howl
-foresight
-fury swipes

so i got my move finally on my 13th try, this took me about 3-4 weeks to do for a single move, now i’m pretty sure there are people who want more then just one but come on

5

I cant evenFind 1

6

I agree with ArtMax and Yang, If is possible choose the move that you want to learn and hidden as Big Mushroom

7

lemme just say…

A. I dont find them
B. They should give u a list of which moves u can take. like what they do wit big/tiny mushy’s

8

I agree with Art,we should atleast get to pick the move we learn so we don’t go through a billion Heart Scales to do it.

9

Yah I agree also.I also think that Heart scales should be less rare in the future and then we move on to the Tutor moves(not the Electivire one) like what we moved on from the Big s.Also its a super rare chance of finding Heart Scales on the floor I have found about 2 or 3 on the floor in Sauna when there was no such thing as Pick up Ability. x.x Another~~~~ thing is that I don’t think they should have the option to let you choose the moves because it is a challenge having to hunt a lot for a certain move lol you can’t make this a little more easier just because it takes forever to get a certain move.We are still fine the way it is but at least make the spawning of Heart Scales a little easier lol(just saying).I won’t vote at all because i’m still kinda ok with the rate and the random moves still.

10

i agree with art as i want to get a good move on my pichu and i have used all my hs on it and i keep getting rubbish moves like lucky chant =/

11

I can agree with what Art has said. The one flaw I see is how if you find a Heart Scale, with a 1% chance and invisible(unless your using the Pick-Up ability to help you) of spawning. After people get one and try for the egg move, MOST pokemon have a 10% chance or less chance of getting one egg move. For the poll, I selected the Move Choice option. because Heart Scales already help in a big way. I think a 1% chance and invisible is good for such a helpful item, but I think Move Choice would help so Heart Scales aren’t wasted, like Yang’s problem. He actually used 51-52 Heart Scales and finally got Dragon Pulse… but 52? Thats such a big waste when those other Heart Scales could help others with egg moves. Leaving the spawn rate of Heart Scales as they are seems like a more useful thing than floor spawns, but that may just be me. If I found more Heart Scales and just got the one egg move I wanted, then I could help other players get Heart Scales they need or may need. Thus, why I picked the Move Choice option.

12

I agree. Heart scales are based on luck… well 53+ is like wasting over a million poke. Yes. A MILLION POKE. And i may have gotten dragon pulse, But it’s not the move I’m solemnly looking for. I still want the move, Dragon rush. Still haven’t obtained it ONCE. I got all the other moves Except Dragon Rush. I believe the number will continue till 100. Anything over 100, is a SERIOUS heart scale problem. Heart scales need to be looked into. It may provide egg moves, but the chance of finding it and getting the move you want is VERY VERY slim. At least the Spawn rate or floor spawns should be suggested for scales. I agree with either one. Floor spawn or move choice.

13

Well…I wouldn’t care if Heart scales changed but it would be nice to. Well I’ve never gotten my hands on an Heart scale so its actually useless to me >_>

14

I like this idea. I would much prefer to see Heart Scales give you a move choice instead of a random move. But i do not thin that their spawn rate should be increased because after all, egg moves should be hard to get, just not as hard as they are now.

15

^ @ Dausk. I honestly think so too. This game needs at least one really rare item that’s super hard to find. Shouldn’t we just change you can pick your move for your hard work on these?